US Gov Sues The Art Institutes for $11 Billion Fraud

 

The Art Institutes, one of the nation’s largest for-profit school systems where people can receive an education in photography, has come under fire. Last month, the US Department of Justice filed a massive lawsuit against the company behind the schools, Education Management Corporation, accusing it of fraudulently collecting $11 billion in government aid by recruiting low-income students for the purpose of collecting student aid money. Whistleblowers claim that students graduate loaded with debt and without the means to pay off the loans, which are then paid for with taxpayer dollars.

David Walker at PDN writes,

At the Art Institute of Pittsburgh campus alone, there were reportedly about 600 photography students pursuing a bachelor of arts or associates degree as of last summer, says Kathleen A. Bittel, the whistleblower whose testimony before a US Senate committee last fall helped trigger the federal lawsuit against EDMC.

[...] “Where are 600 photography graduates going to go? You cannot absorb that many in one city. How are they going to make money?” she says.

Bittel says EDMC had plans last summer to increase its photography student enrollment by adding a 12-15 month diploma to the program. The new degree was intended to attract students who wanted a “quick fix” in the form of a degree they could earn faster than an associate’s degree with minimal effort, Bittel says. “If the bachelors students can’t find jobs, where are the students with [12-month diplomas] going to go?”

One former student they contacted commented that, “It’s like they’re pumping photographers out like little cookie cutters.”

The Art Institutes: Legitimate Photo Schools or Accessories to Fraud? (via DWF)


Image credit: The Art Institute of California – San Francisco by sebastianjt


 
  • Scooleyy

    I’ve been attending this school for years and they dropped me because I failed one class now they won’t let me reattend but my classes can’t transfer to anywhere, now I’m screwed and already have 100 units completed so i’m over halfway done. 

  • Hydra Art

    It’s not only the photography major that is doing this. Most, if not all, the other majors recruit the same way.  Back when I was a student, we saw this, and knew it was wrong. I am glad EDMC will hopefully be paying for this.

  • Philmac

    Hello my fellow Art Institute classmates.  I attended the Art Institute of Atlanta from 2001-2005.  I feel that there are pros and cons to attending an Art Institute.  My advice is for passionate artists to not attend.  I would suggest going to an University and majoring in a Art major and creating a portfolio on your own.  For one it will be cheaper than going to an Art Institute and number two even if you do go to an Art Institute and spend $80,000 – $100,000 you will still have to make the portfolio on your own.  There were instructors that I really enjoyed and I do feel that I learned a lot.  Additionally I was able to transfer to another school and I was able to transfer credits.  But I must say if I knew then what I know now I would have not attended an Art Institute. I would have attended Georgia State, Georgia Tech or UAB and majored in Art and created my own portfolio.  When I say passionate artists I’m referring to people that have the true passion and talent for the arts.  I felt sad for many of my classmates who had never drawn until they arrived at the school.  I had been drawing since age 5.  Many of the instructors would purposely embarrass fellow students art abilities that were not strong artists and the entire time I’m thinking I know that the recruiters practically begged the students to come to the school.  It was just sad.  Lastly I partly blame myself because I should have known something was amiss when just about every car in the Staff parking lot was a Mercedes Benz.

  • Sunchie72

    and maybe learn the difference between their, they’re & there?!?! hahah

  • AISblows

    the problem with AIS that i found was that i graduated with a 3.9 gpa and had what i was told was a stellar portfolio. when i applied for jobs i was told that i had no idea what i was doing and have never been hired to do anything related to what i went to school for. i stopped looking after 2 years as it was clear that AIS really didn’t provide me with the tools i needed to get work. 

  • Francorage

    What about state schools that graduate students with suffocating student debt that aren’t able to find work to pay the loans off?  Why are for-profit schools singled out here? 
    I attended a private, non-profit undergraduate school and a state college for grad school.  I ended up with about $60K in debt and the state school didn’t even ATTEMPT to help me find work.  I’m fine now because I’m a resourceful and frugal person.
    How about a cheer for personal responsibility and an equal investigation into the success rate of state school grads???

  • Kristintastic

    I myself went to the Art Institute in Seattle for only 8 months. I started right after I graduated high school, even after I had been warned by my teachers to not go. I was going for my BFA in Photography. My first term was completely wasted with classes I didn’t even need – they scheduled me in them, I had no say in the matter. The package was worth somewhere around $700 or more, probably, also included in our tuition. Some of the teachers I’m really glad to have met and learned from… others not so much. I won’t get into that. But student housing was absolutely ridiculous. Over $900 a month per person in a studio apartment downtown – the street where crack heads and homeless run rampant – in a building that is now condemned! They also put a hold on my tuition, telling me I wasn’t covered, and I had a bill for $8000. The did not notify me of this until the Friday of Spring Break – THREE DAYS before the new term was supposed to start! I was told to take out a $30,000 loan, which I didn’t even have time to get a co-signer anyway. I said no, and I withdrew that Monday. I moved out two days later, and was charged $400 because I stayed two 1/2 days in housing after the new quarter started. I also was not notified of this until two days before it went to collections. Now my mom (which I have to pay her back) owes 26,000 to Sallie Mae, not to mention the amount of loans I took out. I also should say that they gave her the loan when she was unemployed, which they never should have done in the first place! 

    Now I am going to my local community college, studying something completely different, however still pursuing my photography and have started my own business. I make decent money in waves, but never will I make enough to afford to pay all of it off. 

  • talobx

    My daughter is planning on attending AiPittsburgh in the Fall for Graphic Design.  After reading this article, we are now quite concerned about this decision. 

    Is there ANYone on this forum who attended AiPittsburgh for graphic design and if so, what is the job market for this major? 

    I realize our economy is struggling at the moment and Master Degree students are not finding employment, but aside from this, we really need some input or experience from someone who went through this school.

    I certainly do not want my daughter to be skyhigh in debt from a school that is not offering a future or giving her false pretenses. 

    Hoping to hear from someone.

    Thank you.

  • Dacumosm

    uh, hello? I currently attend Ai of Washington, and I am a film student, granted there are some things the schools could work on, but isn’t it like that for all schools? Although, yes, I do agree that the illegal issue at hand should be dealt with firmly.  I however, do not feel it should be taken out on the students, they are simply going to make a life for themselves.  Also, it’s not just about the degree under your belt, it’s the amount of hard work you put into it and your knowledge based on such.

  • Ericathompson415

    For your “information” i did study for my English classes, i did pay attention in my classes. You can compare every student to “your advantage on a certain topic of education”. Every student have their advantage  and disadvantage in school. If a school accepts a student on his or her “PASSING REQUIREMENTS” of English and Math test. Then why does the Student have to be terminated from school due to the lack of help and acknowledgment in his or her GED classes. Into “political Correct” you, i did student my ass off at this school. I got A’s and B’s in my animation classes. So you can’t put yourself in my shoes or any other student shoes by thinking you can jump to conclusion on this matter of “students being taking advantage of”, you simply can’t. Your response was very “OVER EDUCATED ANS RUDE” thanks for the information.

  • Dog

    this is not English class get a clue.your comment makes you look like you dont have an education yourself.

  • AnonGirl

    I went to the same school. That damn student housing. First of all, the major complex, The Heights, was on the edge of a really dangerous neighborhood. I felt bad for anyone who did not have a car and relied on the school shuttle, which never had any room in it at a certain point in the morning. If that bus got into an accident, there would be at least a dozen injuries.

    Second, that $75 for three months of parking was such a nightmare. The only other available parking was the meters and that was close to 75 cents an hour because it was in Santa Monica. If I wanted free parking I had to park near the the small park.

    Those financial officers were nightmares to deal with. I never qualified for that extra $2500 or something like that for every quarter that other students got.

    Some of my loans are in collection now and they want to garnish my wages. Knowing this investigation is going on makes me not want to give them my money.

    I was in the digital filmmaking program and I actually liked most of my teachers. 

    I like you are frustrated that I was taken for an idiot and wish I can have those years back.

  • Ariel

    I wonder if their is a way to get out of paying them… I was there for a semester and a half and they brought in three different Video Production Directors… One from across the country… Barely knew how to speak English! That is when I decided to stop going, because the school OBVIOUSLY did not know what they were doing… I left, and 6 months later I had students calling me saying they should have listened to me about leaving. The school is a JOKE!

  • Jeff

    Please learn how to communicate using proper grammer, punctuation and spelling. If you can’t learn how to string a sentence together, you’re never going to find a job doing anything other than selling Air Jordans at the mall shoe store.

  • Pjthompson

    Kinkos and Staples were considered my job field as Media Art and Animation. Dont even need a 50k education to work there. They also  guarantee 98% placement rate in your field when u graduate.

  • Pjthompson

    Ya and a lot to be said on location of your school. Your in the heart of the field you went to school at. Over here on the East Coast there not much but a few small studios with personal connection to get into. Also most studios want people with at least 2yr experience in a given specialty. You probably were afforded you parents house to get you through the internships. No nothing guaranteed but Telling thousands of students they can get them jobs in the job field they are training you is fraud. AIC-SF probably the only legit school out of there system they can come through on there promises for your job field.

  • Myestherface

    So what’s going to happen to the students with the debt?

  • Myestherface

    So what’s going to happen to the students with the debt?

  • AI VA BEACH

    i am currently dropping out of the AI in Virginia beach,

    the school is a joke went for 10 weeks and realized, half my teachers had no idea what they were talking about, half the time students are teaching students, not to mention the stupid little events they get you to go to before the enroll you like student carnival day, 

    i went for graphic design and my instructor barley even knew how to use Photoshop

    anyway to make this short if your thinking about going, DONT, its a waste of time and money, you cant even transfer credits to other AIs, the advisors just set you up cause they want your money, think about it nice and hard, is 100,000 dollars worth such a cookie cutter school

  • AI VA sucks

    my advice is to NOT go or at least go to orientations and see for your self how leechy and fake nice the advisory staff can be or simply count how many times they call your house asking you to attend right away, i go to the one in virginia for graphic design, and half the professors dont even no how to use Photoshop, or you spend a whole class learning how to color a flower, the school is a joke, and a waste of extream amount of money, i left after 10 weeks, my advice to your daughter, get a portfolio together and no matter how high or low the gpa, tell her to find a really good school, and u will see who accepts you based off talent, im now accepted to a school in DEL, witch is a branch of pratt a very nice art school in NY, not of my credits even transferred, however i dont mind starting over and paying money for a challenging school thats worth it…..best of luck

  • David Wisniewski

    Art Institute Of Los Angeles falsly accepted me. I didnt have the mathmatical foundation required for the Field of Study. I made my self clear to the school before hand, I was going to go to community college to take math classes before I went there. They insured me If i got a specific score on a math test they gave, I would be fine and wouldnt need the math classes at the community college. It was a lie. When I got to 2nd math class my teacher told me I need to of taken previous math courses, Which was why I was going to go to a Community College to take those classes. I ended up dropping out before I built up for debt. There was a total of 3-4 math classes I need to of taken to understand that one course alone. 

    Now I have $21,000 in debt because the school pretty much made me beleive I didnt need to take those math classes at a community college

  • Anonymous

    I would love to go back to school and finish for my BA in graphic design but can’t afford the cost of loans and due to AI not being a credited school only about 1/3 of my credits will transfer if that to other universities. Just give us our money back or take away our debt so that we can have peace of mind to start over and make a better school / education choice you CROOKS!

  • None

    Good job spelling grammer (sic) correctly, teach.

  • None

    a big part of your success was a BA from a real school and work experience, even in an unrelated field. this is not the case for most people that attend these schools and fail to gain employment afterward.

  • Eliot Trimberger

    I was about to go to the Art Institute and the first thing that came to mind when I saw the inflated costs and no promise of a job after graduation (because they were new) was the University of Phoenix. I read on a blog on a different website that if you even have University of Phoenix on your resume, you aren’t going to get hired, at least not by anybody that is legitimate. I can only assume the same thing with respect to the Art Institute. $500 a credit is free labor at the point of a gun when I can go to my community college and for the same price get five credits for what I am paying for one credit. I don’t want to put a school on my resume that is being sued by the federal government! I’ll go to a school that has a reputation for high job placement in the field I graduate in, which is going to be television and video production. 

    If you want to be successful in the media arts, and get true hands on experience, move to Los Angeles or New York. That’s where the studios are located. 

  • parentofaistudent

    First of all, thank you Paul Zdepski. As I read through the article and the comments (I received the link from my exwife after my daughter was accepted), I notice a lot of people who say that the school didn’t get them a job. Job placement is a risk. Everything you do has a risk associated with it. How many kids grow up playing little league, pop warner, or some other sport that do not go on to be in the pros. Do your research, make a plan, don’t commit to a school you do not personally go visit.
    My daughter and I went to a visit to AI of Jax and I was very impressed. We had a one-on-one with the dept head for the culinary school, walked through all of the other schools labs and she had to go through an interview process to see if she was the type of person to even go to ai. 
    My daughter still plans to go starting in the summer on a scholarship. Work hard for what you want and don’t expect others to do it for you.

  • Anonymous

     I graduated in 2003 from AIP with an associate degree in industrial design technology. I strongly recommend taking the over $100,000 that you plan on owing this school, and just start your own graphic design firm. The best experience is just doing it.

  • Xedi89x

    wow I went to the open house today. I wanted to go for Graphic Design now reading this i’m having second thoughts.

  • Jefferson2721

    I’m an old AIFL graduate. I don’t believe they even offer the AAS degree in Advertising design I received in 1990. My experience is very similar to what is being voiced here, even 22 years later. Many students with NO talent somehow being sheperded through class after class. Don’t mean to sound arrogant, that’s just the way it was. Childish work from people and everyone knew it. Being a little bit older student at the time, many of the instructors befriended me and gave me their opinions privately concerning this. With regard to job placement…no assistance there whatsoever. Eventually, I ended up taking a job at a neon sign shop as a production monkey. Didn’t need that coveted degree for that position since a friend of mine got me the job. I planned on taking it temporarily “until something better came along”. Guess what? 22 years and 4 sign companys later I was still in the neon sign industry, only now as a glass blower. Didn’t get to do much design work, but after many burn scars and thousands of repetitions I became a respected person known in my neck of the woods for high quality neon signs. Pay was okay, but I think to back when the faculty was filling my head with delusions of grandeur, I thought I would be much further along than that. Now, technology has caught up to me, as it always does to a craftsman. Replacing experience and skill with electronics that a trained monkey could perform. Why pay me a decent wage when anybody can install LED’s? Also, the sign business has been hurt very badly by the economic downturn. Businesses aren’t buying as before. And there is a guy with a computer and plotter on every street corner practically giving work away to keep his doors open. My experience stems from the fact that my ambition to become a professional illustrator was side tracked by life. I got married, had kids, and couldn’t give up the job I had to pay bills and feed my kids etc. So now, 22 years later I’m hoping to continue my education by pursuing a BS/BA in hopes of enhancing job prospects. And btw…I STILL HAVE SOME OF THOSE DAMN STUDENT LOANS TO PAY BACK!! 

  • guest

    I am currently going to AI-Nashville and from the moment I realized how they were,it has been hell.As I enter the school,it feels like I’m entering a prison.They are charging me late fees and charges out of no where when all I have been doing is paying them the exact monthly payment,at the exact time,on the exact date.When I asked them where these charges were coming from they literally had nothing to say to me.I brought receipts and any kind of proof I could.Before I knew how they were,I signed up for student housing.The guy who is the department chair of financial aid told,promised,and signed a contract with me stating he would not make me pay once cent to move in because I explained,and gave proof,of my situation to him.The other day,I received a letter from them telling me to pay off thousands of dollars for student housing.I took it to the guy and told him they needed to fix this and I’m moving out.He told me they would charge me even more if I moved out.
    Not only that but my GPA was a 3.8 and I failed one class and they dropped it to a 1.0.For one class.I failed it because they wouldn’t let me drop it since it was past dropping time.
    Not only that but I have holds,which they are threatening that if I don’t take care of them they will kick me out.One of them is for making a 1.0,another for charges coming out of the nowhere,one for student housing which I no longer live in due to the bad environment and constant drama,and the last one for not giving them my shot records when I did and have proof of.
    Every comment I have seen on here of people complaining about this school is exactly what I’m going through.Half the teachers don’t know how to teach,treat you like shit because they think they are high mighty for working there,and/or put you down any chance they get.
    I fucking hate this school.